Barnegat, NJ Listings Dining Shopping Leisure Highest Rated Dining Clemmy’s $ 28 reviews Seafood, New American 290 Route 9 NWaretown, NJ 08758 Sun Harbor Seafood & Grill $$ 101 reviews Bars, Seafood (609) 622-6190 451 E Bay AveBarnegat Township, NJ 08005 LA Cabanita $ 98 reviews Mexican (609) 488-2056 621 E Bay AveManahawkin, NJ 08050 Manera's Restaurant $$ 222 reviews New American, Seafood, Steakhouses (609) 756-5420 291 Rte 72 EManahawkin, NJ 08050 Sweet Jenny's $$ 83 reviews Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Breakfast & Brunch, Burgers (609) 698-2228 688 E Bay AveBarnegat Township, NJ 08005 3 Flags Restaurant $ 43 reviews Portuguese, Spanish, Italian (609) 891-2645 121 S Main StLacey Township, NJ 08731 The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House $$$ 544 reviews Seafood, Bars, Steakhouses (609) 488-1327 1201 E Bay AveStafford Township, NJ 08050 The Mainland Kitchen & Pub $$ 140 reviews American, Beer Gardens, Venues & Event Spaces (609) 481-6120 151 Rte 72 EManahawkin, NJ 08050 Ott's Good Earth Garden $$ 254 reviews Seafood, Vegetarian, Steakhouses (609) 597-8828 771 S Main StWest Creek, NJ 08092 Element Restaurant & Bar $$ 332 reviews Steakhouses, Sushi Bars, Seafood (609) 488-2172 635 Rt 72 WStafford Township, NJ 08050 East Bay Italian Grill $ 102 reviews Pizza, Italian (609) 994-2353 696 E Bay AveBarnegat, NJ 08005 Mud City Crab House $$$ 506 reviews Seafood (609) 978-3660 1185 E Bay AveManahawkin, NJ 08050 Dolce Liberta $$ 126 reviews Italian, Seafood, Gluten-Free (609) 549-3532 100 McKinley AveManahawkin, NJ 08050 Doyle's Pour House $$ 192 reviews American, Pubs (609) 660-8300 345 S Main StBarnegat, NJ 08005 Lefty's Tavern $$ 182 reviews Bars, New American, Seafood (609) 607-0707 547 N Main StBarnegat, NJ 08005 Mr. J’s Deli $ 41 reviews Delis, Breakfast & Brunch, Wraps (609) 488-2620 495 Rte 72 EManahawkin, NJ 08050 Lunch Box On 9 $ 49 reviews Breakfast & Brunch, Sandwiches, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt (609) 549-5125 542 Rt 9Waretown, NJ 08758 Zanos Italian Market $$ 109 reviews Italian, Caterers (609) 660-0432 360 N Main StWaretown, NJ 08758 La Jarochita $$ 116 reviews Mexican (609) 994-2008 449 E Bay AveManahawkin, NJ 08050 Pintos Porch $ 40 reviews Tacos, Burgers, Sandwiches (609) 242-5418 657 E Bay AveManahawkin, NJ 08050 El Tepeyac $$ 146 reviews Mexican (609) 549-5511 511 Rte 72Stafford Township, NJ 08050 East Bay Cafe $ 6 reviews Coffee & Tea, Soup, Sandwiches (609) 622-8257 980 E Bay AveManahawkin, NJ 08050 39° North $ 21 reviews Waffles, Breakfast & Brunch, Sandwiches (609) 597-4771 32 E Bay AveManahawkin, NJ 08050